Maddie’s Haddie: When you know, you know

Maddie Connolly, a first-time paleontology volunteer, put her day one find into Tylor Birthisel’s hands that evening, during what’s known as Campfire Show-and-Tell. This is where Birthisel, the Natural History Museum of Utah’s Paleo Preparation Lab and Fieldwork manager, holds court in the circle and volunteers bring him something cool to look at—to see what he knows. Often, he knows a lot.

He’s a paleontologist and geologist by training and hopes to finish his master’s degree in the next year or two. But one of his main roles—for which he is revered and beloved—is recruiting, training and managing volunteers in the field, which you could say he enjoys the most.

PHOTO CREDIT: NHMU

Tylor Birthisel in the field next to Maddie Connolly’s discovery.

The volunteers really “dig” Birthisel’s skills too. “It’s amazing,” Connolly reported. “He can look at an eye socket fragment, or a piece of one toe, and immediately recognize the ridges and bumps, identify the species, tell you a dinosaur’s life story, hopes and dreams…”

So how does he do that?

When he first started in paleontology about 18 years ago, Birthisel is the first to admit he couldn’t tell the difference between any of these animals or what bones he was even looking at. “I’ve developed the eye because I’ve worked in these areas for so long,” he said.

“Based on the kneecap Connolly uncovered,” (which is actually the distal end of the femur, so, in essence, the knee), he explains, “I can narrow it down pretty quickly just based on the dimensions of the bone and comparing it to the mental inventory in my head.”

With that trained eye, it’s a quick process of elimination. “I knew it was a hadrosaur,” said Birthisel, “and that we only have two known hadrosaurs (duck-billed dinosaurs) in Grand Staircase: Gryposaurus and Parasaurolophus.”

At this point, Birthisel was unsure if it was Gryposaurus or Parasaurolophus. If he were a betting person, he said he would have put money on Gryposaurus, because that is the more common of the two.

“In my heart, I was secretly hoping for a Parasaurolophus,” Birthisel confessed, “but just because that is the animal I am studying for my master’s thesis.“

Breaking it down: How Maddie found her Haddie

According to Birthisel, a big reason why Connolly stumbled on this fossil is her keen intuition and some good old-fashioned beginner’s luck.

In Grand Staircase, the rock is generally a salt-and-pepper grey. Fresh dinosaur bones tend to be a chocolate brown color, in part because the sun and environmental conditions haven’t bleached them yet. But when they’ve been sitting out, they’re kind of a tan or buff color.

PHOTO CREDIT: NHMU

A photo of Maddie Connolly’s discovery showing color contrast.

Sometimes they have an orange hue, which was what Connolly first noticed. But often, a closer look at a rock may dash hope; it can be petrified wood, or just weathered or oxidized rocks that take on that orangey color. Many paleontologists have been fooled by these tricksters at first glance when hiking the backcountry, and the older more “experienced” folks will walk past them.

Color and shape are good initial clues to give things a second glance. And if all else fails and you don’t know? “There’s always the lick test,” said Birthisel, which works because even though the bones are fossilized they still preserve the microscopic pores that suck in a bit of moisture and allows it to stick to your tongue. “It works!”

On the first day of her first time out in the field. Connolly’s instincts were spot on, but she’s the first one to cop to a fair amount of luck, which Birthisel confirms.

“I always joke with the newbies that they find the cool stuff because they don’t have as many preconceived notions,” Birthiselsaid.

He confesses that he probably would have stepped over the area Connolly spotted and headed into the badlands further. “You just assume that the space she was in has been combed over a lot already,” he adds, and then jokes, “And Maddie just wasn’t jaded like I am, right?”

Connolly attributes at least part of her success to her training as a chemical engineer and a researcher. “I’ll admit, I’m really meticulous, so I probably moved painstakingly slowly so I wouldn’t miss anything.”

She was rewarded for this approach with her find, which intrigued Birthisel, to say the least. He planned to head out to the site the next morning, along with Randy Johnson, one of NHMU’s expert veteran volunteers.

The “Jurassic Park” moment

When Birthisel got to the site, he was shocked and delighted. Connolly had uncovered a fair amount of one of the legs relatively easily.

“It was ‘Jurassic Park’-style, where she had basically just brushed some rock and dirt away,” Birthisel remarked, adding, “Often it’s more like hammering and drilling through hundreds of pounds of rock.”

Plus, the more the team brushed and uncovered, it became clear just how rare the find was, and assured the team that, as Birthisel put it, “This one was definitely coming home with us.”

You see, the NHMU team can afford to be selective. And during these fieldwork days, Birthisel and other paleontology experts are typically walking back and forth between volunteers’ finds, doing an on-site evaluation.

PHOTO CREDIT: NHMU

More of the fossil revealed showing the articulated leg bones.

“We don’t necessarily collect everything,” explained Birthisel. “Sometimes it’s cool that someone found a leg bone, but it’s an isolated bone. And if we can narrow it down considerably to the group of dinosaurs, I can assess whether it’s going to be scientifically enlightening for us.”

Birthisel and the team still document and record the sites they find—even in Grand Staircase, where NHMU has been collecting for 20 years—they just don’t bring everything back to the museum.

“There are a few factors that justify bringing it back to the museum,” Birthisel shared, “like how complete the skeleton is; what type of animal it is; and the rarity of that animal.”

What was remarkable about Connolly’s find is two-fold. First off, the femur, tibia and fibula were associated to indicate that most of the leg was articulated, meaning that these—and maybe multiple bones—may still be life position.

“Basically it means that the bones aren’t scattered,” Birthisel said. “It’s almost like the animal died and got buried pretty quickly, so the bones are still connected in a life-like skeleton.”

This doesn’t happen a lot; bones are often scattered by predators who pick the carcass over, or that the bones on the surface get eroded and pulled apart by the weather.

“The fact that all the bones were articulated and still together was a really good sign,” said Birthisel. “We were sure that Maddie’s discovery was worth spending more time on.” And it was.

It didn’t take a long time to see that there was a complete foot on the end of the leg, which led to a pelvis in the other direction. And because the rock wasn’t super hard, the team of Connolly, Birthisel, Randy, and a few of the other volunteers worked fast—in paleontology standards anyway.

It wasn’t long before the team knew what they were looking at: a juvenile Gryposaurus.

How he knew

“I already had it narrowed down to the group [hadrosaurs], and once we started uncovering the pelvis (hips) I was able to get a pretty good idea,” Birthisel said.

He explains that the pelvis in Gryposaurus is different from Parasaurolophus, so that was pretty clear from the shapes. As to its age, Birthisel saw that the size of the limbs was about two feet long. The limbs of adult Gryposaurus can get up to five feet long. Additionally, he noted that it didn’t appear that all of the bones had fused yet—a trait commonly found in adult animals.

So, Birthisel, Connolly, and a few excited volunteers knew what they had. But they also knew that they had to move it—and carefully.

The story is the second of a series, and was originally published on the NHMU blog.

Beth Mitchell is senior manager of external relations at the Natural History Museum of Utah. Our mission is to illuminate the natural world and the place of humans within it. In addition to housing outstanding exhibits for the public, NHMU is a research museum. Learn more.

Media Contacts

Beth MitchellSenior manager of external communications, Natural History Museum of Utah
Office: 801 581 4433 Mobile: 917 288 0240